CF or Aluminum?

I had planned on making these parts out of aluminum, but I’ve been thinking maybe I should go with CF instead. I have two parts- a strut and a base. The photos of both are attached. These are not to scale or exactly as I am going to make, but it is a good representation of what I am looking to create. Both items are 8" in length. These structures need to support about 150 pounds. Assume the base is resting on an immovable object.

The thickness of the strut in the photo is 3/8", but the actual strut may be as much as 1/2". The original plan was to take a 5/8" piece of plate aluminum and cnc out an airfoil shape that is 1/2" at it’s thickest points. But I was thinking that maybe I could make a mold and make it from carbon fiber instead. Maybe with a foam core.

What do you think? Which would be easier and/or make a better product? Thanks!

easiest? probably laser cut. but smaller lasers dont like that think of aluminum, so may be forced to go waterjet.
on the 2nd piece, laser or water and weld on the tabs.

Thanks. Maybe I should rephrase. Which would be easier to do in your garage? If you don’t have a laser or waterjet cutter in your garage, that is. lol

I guess the real question is, is it possible to do this in CF, and if so, how difficult would it be. Any examples of something similar? Thanks.

Some things to consider: If you want to use a core, you need to think about how you are going to trim your part, cut holes etc. because you don’t want to expose the core. If I was doing this DIY in my garage… I would plan out an Option A which didn’t include a core, only laminate layers & Option B, which includes a core. Work out how each option would need to be built and see if you really need the core.

If you want to use composites I think your first triangle shape bracket would be do-able, and definitely the easiest of the two. But remove the cutouts so it’s one solid piece with just the two mounting holes. You might have to redesign it to have more material around the holes - much more if you want the core material to go right around the holes as well. But I wouldn’t try that myself… I would just have the core in the middle of the part and build up extra layers of laminate around the holes. For the edges you might be able to make a lip that comes out at 90º, if that would be suitable for your usage. Even a small amount of lip would add probably a lot of strength to the part. Have a search here for the car ramps that DDCompound built - they’re basically an upside down “U” shape.

For your 2nd part with the 3 tabs, well… anything is possible, but for a DIY garage job I can see that being a lot of work and needing to be produced as multiple sections and bonded together. Probably much, much easier and cheaper to just go aluminium on that one. Find an engineering shop that will cut the pieces and weld the tabs, job done. At least that is what I would do. Unless I wanted to turn it into a real project and didn’t need the part for at least a year or two!

Hope that helps some.